The president rejected the representation of FBR in case of a female complainant


Islamabad: President Dr Arif Alvi has reprimanded the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) for harassing a taxpayer who filed a complaint with the Federal Tax Ombudsman (FTO) against the Board over the non-issuance of a genuine refund.
The president rejected the representation of FBR against the order of the FTO by observing that the case had repeatedly been mishandled and the conduct of FBR officers amounted to harassment.
He regretted observing that the refund application filed in 2015, which by law was required to be disposed of within 60 days, remained pending due to inaction by FBR for almost five years and was taken up only after the complaint was filed with FTO, and that too in a vindictive manner.
However, the FBR once again charged the complainant on the same issue under another section of the Income Tax Ordinance.
The FTO, once again, reprimanded FBR on account of harassing the taxpayer. Instead of implementing the FTO’s decision, the FBR once again filed a representation with the president.
The president, while rejecting the representation, observed that the conduct of FBR officers was tantamount to maladministration, adding that neglect, inattention, incompetence, inefficiency, ineptitude, arbitrariness and administrative excess in the discharge of duties were also the acts of maladministration.
He regretted that due care had not been taken in processing the case and further asked FBR to deal with the matter in accordance with the law and take a holistic view without any prejudice/bias and personal grudges.
As per details, Rukhsana Kanwal (the complainant) had filed complaints for tax years 2015 to 2019 against the non-issuance of tax refund with FTO.
The Mohtasib through its consolidated order dated March 20, 2020 had recommended disposing of the complainant’s refund applications for all the years as per law after providing her with the opportunity of hearing.
The tax officers instead of issuing the refund, first charged the complainant arbitrarily without giving the taxpayer the opportunity of being heard with turnover tax under section 113 of the Income Tax Ordinance and when this charge was annulled by the Commissioner Inland Revenue-CIR (Appeals), the officer again charged the complainant disregarding the order of CIR (Appeal) under section 122(5A) on the ground that a gift was received through the non-banking channel while deliberately ignoring the irrefutable evidence filed by the complainant of banking transaction.
The president upheld the order of FTO wherein the FBR was ordered to hold an internal inquiry into the glaring incidence of maladministration by the concerned officers on account of creating problems for those who seek justice at the forum of FTO.
He further directed FBR to ensure cooperation and discourage such typical vindictive reactions by its officers.
SOURCE: APP

Wildlife force deployed as no-bird zones enforced near Lahore airport
- 2 hours ago
PTI launches 90-day ‘do or die’ movement across Pakistan
- 3 hours ago

Sindh police give 10-day deadline to personnel to quit gutka, mawa use
- 43 minutes ago

High risk near rivers as Tarbela spillways open today
- 2 hours ago

Kashmir Martyrs’ Day: A historic reminder of struggle and sacrifice
- 3 hours ago
WhatsApp introduces new feature to show how many people are typing in group chats
- 36 minutes ago

Samsung Galaxy Unpacked 2025: the 7 biggest announcements
- 13 hours ago

Galaxy Z Fold 7 hands-on: Samsung finally made the foldables we’ve been asking for
- 13 hours ago
Rawalpindi to Multan bus meets accident; 5 in critical condition
- 3 hours ago
WWE icon Goldberg bids farewell after 27-year wrestling career
- 3 hours ago

Yanks' Rodon replaces Fried on AL All-Star team
- 12 hours ago
Iran confirms assassination attempt on President Pezeshkian amid Israeli airstrikes
- 2 hours ago